top of page

Where Rome Kept Watch Over Peter and Paul

Writer: Fr. Scott Haynes
Fr. Scott Haynes
12 minutes ago
5 min read

Fr. Scott Haynes



The Dedication of the Basilicas of Saints Peter and Paul

November 18 · Feast Day Meditation


Around the year 200, a Roman Christian named Gaius offered to take a visitor to two places outside the city. One lay on the Vatican hill, the other along the road that led to the port of Ostia. “I can show the trophies of the apostles,” he wrote.¹ A Roman hearing the word trophies might have pictured captured weapons displayed after a military victory. Gaius had in mind the memorials of two men whom Rome had put to death. Christians knew the way to both, and if his visitor wished to see what victory looked like, Gaius was willing to show him.


On November 18 the Church still makes, in her liturgy, the pilgrimage that Gaius proposed. She commemorates the dedication of Saint Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican and Saint Paul Outside the Walls on the Ostian Way. The observance has a special resonance in 2026. On November 18, exactly four hundred years will have passed since Pope Urban VIII dedicated the present Saint Peter’s. Saint Paul’s shares the liturgical commemoration, although the dedication of its present building took place on a December morning more than two centuries later.²


The little shrine beneath Michelangelo’s dome


A pilgrim entering Saint Peter’s naturally looks up. Michelangelo’s dome rises above Bernini’s great bronze canopy, which in turn shelters the papal altar. Yet the oldest part of the story lies in the opposite direction. Beneath the altar, on what was once the southern slope of the Vatican hill, stood a modest grave near the circus associated with Nero’s persecution of the Christians. About a century after Peter’s martyrdom, someone erected a small funerary shrine there. Archaeologists call it the “Trophy of Gaius.”³


Some of the most moving evidence comes from the pilgrims who found their way to that little shrine before Constantine built his church. They scratched the names of Christ and Peter into the plaster of a nearby wall. A separate fragment from the shrine’s red wall, scarcely more than two inches across, preserves part of a Greek inscription. One proposed reading is “Peter is here.” Another understands the surviving letters as a prayer, “Peter in peace.” Too little plaster survives to settle the reading. What survives in abundance are the marks left by people who came close enough to touch the wall and wanted to leave a word there.³


When Constantine built the first great basilica in the fourth century, he enclosed the little shrine in marble. Later builders observed a remarkable fidelity to that spot. Gregory the Great placed an altar above it. Callistus II built another above Gregory’s, and Clement VIII another above his. A pilgrim standing before the papal altar today is looking across the place where, long before there was a dome on the Roman skyline, a Christian once steadied a hand against the plaster to scratch Peter’s name.³


One detail of the dedication in 1626 deserves to be remembered alongside the names of the great architects. As part of the ancient rite, Urban VIII traced the letters of the alphabet in ashes spread upon the floor. Imagine the sight of the pope bending to form those simple letters inside a building on which generations of craftsmen had labored. For a moment the immense floor became a writing surface, as the plaster beside Peter’s grave had been centuries before.⁴


The apostle on the road to the sea


To find Paul’s memorial, Gaius would have led his visitor out along the Ostian Way. The basilica’s familiar name, Saint Paul Outside the Walls, preserves that geography. Roman Christian tradition holds that Paul was beheaded under Nero and buried along this road. Constantine raised a church at the place where Christians already honored his memory. By the end of the fourth century, a far larger basilica with five aisles had risen there. Beneath the present papal altar, a marble slab still bears a spare Latin inscription, PAULO APOSTOLO MART, “To Paul, apostle and martyr.”⁵


The history of Saint Paul’s also preserves a small kindness easily overlooked in an account of emperors and popes. Around the beginning of the sixth century, Pope Symmachus provided lodgings near the basilica for the poorest pilgrims. Someone who had walked the Ostian Way with little money could come to pray at Paul’s grave and find a place to sleep. It was a fitting work of mercy beside the tomb of an apostle who knew from experience what it meant to arrive in a strange city and depend upon someone opening a door.⁶


The night Saint Paul’s burned


For some fourteen centuries the great basilica stood on the Ostian Way. Then, during the night of July 15–16, 1823, fire swept through it. Among the objects that survived was a medieval wooden figure of Saint Paul. The statue still bears marks of the fire. A visitor who sees it today can glimpse something the polished marble of the rebuilt church can scarcely convey about what Rome lost that night.⁷


Pope Leo XII appealed for help, asking that the surviving portions be used in rebuilding the basilica according to its ancient form. The gifts that followed make one of the loveliest chapters in its history. Tsar Nicholas I of Russia sent malachite and lapis lazuli for the altars of the transept. Muhammad Ali, the Muslim ruler of Egypt, gave alabaster columns. Paul had spent his life carrying the Gospel from one people to another. Centuries later, an Orthodox sovereign and a Muslim ruler helped Roman Catholics raise a roof over his grave.⁷


On December 10, 1854, Blessed Pius IX consecrated the rebuilt Saint Paul’s. Bishops from around the world were already in Rome for the proclamation of the dogma of the Immaculate Conception two days earlier. Many stayed for the dedication, and their names were engraved along the walls of the apse. There is something particularly apt about that gathering. Paul’s surviving letters are full of names, the friends, hosts, fellow laborers, and distant congregations whom he carried in his prayers. When his basilica rose again, the Church filled its walls with names.⁷


Perhaps the best guide to the observance of November 18 is still Gaius. He could offer his visitor neither the sight of Michelangelo’s dome nor the colors of Egyptian alabaster. What he could offer was more personal. He knew where the Christians of Rome went to remember Peter and Paul, and he was willing to take a stranger there. Across the centuries, countless others have done much the same. Someone marked a grave, someone gave a pilgrim a bed, someone sent stone for a ruined church. Every November the Church takes up that work of hospitality once more and leads another generation to the places where the fisherman of Galilee and the tentmaker of Tarsus gave their final witness to Christ.


Notes


  1. Gaius of Rome, “From a Dialogue or Disputation Against Proclus,” fragment 1, preserved in Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History 2.25.6–7. newadvent.org

  2. Italian Art Society, “November 18th Is the Memorial of the Dedication of the Basilicas of St. Peter and of St. Paul,” November 18, 2018; “Urban VIII,” Vatican Notes 13, no. 4; Papal Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, “The Fire on the Night between the 15th and 16th of July 1823.” Italian Art Society

  3. Pietro Zander, “The Tomb of Saint Peter,” Papal Basilica of Saint Peter. basilicasanpietro.va

  4. “The Dedication of the Basilicas of Ss Peter and Paul,” New Liturgical Movement, November 2025. newliturgicalmovement.org

  5. Papal Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, “History” and “The Tomb.” Saint Paul Outside-the-Walls

  6. Papal Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, “From the 5th to the 8th Century.” Saint Paul Outside-the-Walls

  7. Papal Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, “The Fire on the Night between the 15th and 16th of July 1823” and “Jubilees.” Saint Paul Outside-the-Walls

Comments


bottom of page